Samantha Brick, by her own admission, is God’s fucking gift to men. So much so, that she felt it essential to tell the whole world about it.
We all read good old Sam’s article with mock-sympathy, thinking ourselves mighty hilarious when we smacked our lips in sarcasm and said ‘Oh, it must be *soooooo* difficult to be that attractive, all the ATTENTION she must get, all the gifts, the compliments, the good-looking men pawning after her…oh how AWFUL.’
And then we read how poor old Sam had been scorned by other women because of her immense beauty; jealous women who, according to her, had absolutely no sense of ‘Sisterhood’. And we said to ourselves, ‘well they’re probably just tired of listening to the stupid cow bang on about how beautiful she is’.
And then we looked at the photograph of her. And went: ‘Oh’.
‘Oh,’ we said. ‘This woman is not really as beautiful as I imagined. In fact, she, is, dare I say it, plain.’ (Bonus points if you can tell me which Gilbert and Sullivan classic the last five words of that sentence are a quote from.) Some of us even uttered incredulously… ‘Is this some kind of a JOKE?!’
Now, I read an article in Grazia yesterday (not something I choose to do often) which vehemently defended Samantha Brick. It argued that Samantha Brick is a woman who chose to define herself as beautiful, and, as a result of this, was punished by society. Women, it argued, have been taught that they must be self-effacing, self-depreciating and modest. To be confident, to be proud of one’s physical appearance is to be vain and arrogant. It argued: why should this woman be met with such animosity, not only during the experiences she has apparently had with other women throughout her life, but now as she comes out to speak about her difficulties.
And, do you know what, that actually made a bit of sense to me. And I was forced to reassess my reaction to Samantha’s article.
I realised the following things: Samantha’s article was about how women are continuously judged on their appearance… which is what I immediately did when I saw her photograph. (Ah, I am a hypocrite it seems – well, it’s not the first time that’s happened!) I also realised that while I write a lot about the plight of women whose beauty is not represented in magazines, I do not write about the scorn and jealousy many women who happen to conform to stereotypical images of beauty are met with. I also realised, I am not always able to practise what I preach and that I am perhaps more judgmental than perhaps I would like to admit.
And despite all these lovely little epiphanies…
I still couldn’t quite buy into Grazia’s idea that Samantha Brick was actually some sort of feminist hero.
Don’t get me wrong. I love the type of woman who can stand there are say, ‘I think I’m pretty fucking attractive but I deserve to be treated respectfully regardless of what I look like.’ I aim to BE that sort of woman. I would love to be able to wake up in the morning and say: ‘Serafina, you look smoking hot today’. I am all for women feeling proud of their bodies, feeling beautiful, and expressing these feelings. I am aware of the problems many women face because of their appearances and the fact that they are judged by them constantly (hey, that’s pretty much the only thing I blog about, right?). The problem is Samantha Brick came across as a symbol of none of these things. Samantha Brick came across not as strong, but as weak. She came across not as self-confident, but as arrogant. And, also, I am afraid to say, I believe strongly that a fair degree of hyperbole was used in her story.
From my pop-psychological perspective, a person who needs to reiterate their beauty or superior status time and time again is actually someone who feels very low about themselves. They are someone who, throughout their lives, hasn’t received much genuine praise or love from others. The praise they have received they might have become disillusioned with for whatever reason; perhaps because it had an agenda, or perhaps because it was a by-product of manipulation, or perhaps it was because the one person who did praise them let them down. So, this person realises that they are not going to receive enough genuine praise, enough love or validation, to survive; desperately, they start to praise themselves. They lock themselves in a deluded world and play the princess that everyone has mistaken for a pauper.
(Aladdin, anyone?)
And this is actually where all of this Samantha Brick nonsense gets a bit sad and a bit real. In some of her other articles Samantha has revealed to us that her current husband has threatened to divorce her if she gets fat, that her previous husband’s mantra was ‘you can never be too rich or too thin’ and that she has a history of insecurity specifically related to her being overweight as a child that has now evolved into what sounds like a raging eating disorder (‘If I have a bar of chocolate, I’ll miss a meal’, ‘I’m too scared of gaining weight to consider getting pregnant’). I think this says it all really. This is a woman with some serious issues. A woman who wrote in one of her articles, ‘I was a ‘chubby child’ – its psychological legacy has shaped my entire life, from the way I eat to the men I married to the job I do.’ Samantha, in the depths of her delusion, believes that it has led her to make positive choices, when in fact, clearly, it has led her to choose husbands who will continue to punish and remind her of her insecurities despite the fact she is no longer overweight. Not only this, but by sharing her experiences with the world, she has subconsciously created a platform on which people can berate and mock her appearance. Poor old Samantha (look how the sarcasm has disappeared, the mock-sympathy no longer mocking) is speaking out from a very confused, painful, distressed and unhappy place.
Samantha believes she is a victim of the women who scorned her for her beauty. I believe she is a victim of her own demons. What a shame that she cannot see this, what a shame that she has chosen a job (and a newspaper to write for) that will ever allow her to pander to them, what a shame she is surrounding herself with lovers and strangers who will ensure she remains in this difficult place.
What a shame I had to read so many articles on the Daily Mail website to write this blog post!
And for all you people who haven’t had the pleasure of reading Samantha’s articles, they’re all HERE: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/search.html?s=&authornamef=Samantha+Brick
Lucky, LUCKY, you!